Love, Italian style: The infamous “scandale” behind Elizabeth Taylor’s Bulgari brooch

Midway through the exhibition “Italian Style: Fashion Since 1945,” up through January 4 at the MIA, the gallery called Hollywood on the Tiber spotlights the role of films and celebrities in popularizing Italian fashion worldwide in the 1950s and ’60s. Many of the objects in this section boast high-profile provenances, having been worn by Audrey Hepburn, Ava Gardner, Lee Radziwill, Maria Callas, and other famous folks. But one item stands out: a Bulgari brooch—studded with colorless, brown, and yellow diamonds—once owned by Elizabeth Taylor.

The brooch was given to Taylor for her 30th birthday, in February 1962, by her then-husband Eddie Fisher. It was accompanied by matching earrings and a ring. At the time, Taylor was in Rome filming Cleopatra, one of the most indulgent movies ever made, and had just embarked on her one lasting love affair—with Bulgari jewelry. Taylor later remarked, “Undeniably, one of the biggest advantages to working on Cleopatra in Rome was Bulgari’s nice little shop. I used to visit Gianni Bulgari in the afternoons and we’d sit in what he called the ‘money room’ and swap stories…And the jewelry? The exclusive crème de la crème pieces were tucked away in a small room.” One senses that Gianni frequently granted Taylor access to that small little room after their afternoon chats. By the time of her death, in 2011, Taylor had amassed an impressive jewelry collection and many of her prized pieces were Bulgari jewels.

Elizabeth Taylor on the lap of Eddie Fisher, her husband at the time, on the set of "Cleopatra" in Rome in early 1962. Richard Burton, her husband to be, would pry her away from Fisher before the end of the year.

Taylor on the lap of Eddie Fisher, her husband at the time, on the set of “Cleopatra” in Rome in early 1962. Richard Burton, looking on, was already prying her away.

The gift was a last-ditch effort by Fisher to salvage their relationship; it was clear that Taylor had fallen for her married co-star, Richard Burton. Soon after the birthday gift, Fisher and Taylor split, and the Cleopatra co-stars eventually took up residence together, despite the fact that they were both still married to other people. Taylor kept her gems and Fisher sent her Bulgari’s bill. She paid it. Fisher then embarked on a nightclub tour of America and opened every night with the song “Arrivaderci Roma.”

Even today, the story of the Taylor-Burton affair seems dramatic and a little risqué. But probably not worthy of the condemnation from movie executives, politicians, and church leaders that the scandal—known as “Le Scandale”—elicited at the time. Taylor, in particular, was criticized in the American and Italian press for being a homewrecker who “devoured husbands” because many recalled that not too long before she had pried Eddie Fisher from his marriage to America’s sweetheart, Debbie Reynolds—despite the fact that Taylor and Reynolds were close friends. Taylor’s fitness as a mother was called into question. The Catholic Church chimed in with their weekly paper, L’Osservatore della Domenica, condemning her for “erotic vagrancy.”

Elizabeth Taylor with Richard Burton—wearing the brooch from Eddie Fisher.

Taylor with Burton—wearing the brooch from Eddie Fisher.

Reactions were just as extreme back in the United States, where a Georgia congresswoman and an Ohio representative tried to bar Taylor and Burton from returning to the U.S. in order to protect the nation’s delicate moral fiber from coming into dangerous contact with the ill-behaved lovers. Meanwhile, Cleopatra ran over schedule and over budget—largely due to the offstage antics of the co-stars—to such a degree that 20th Century Fox execs fired the film’s producer and director, and then went after the leading actors with a $50 million lawsuit. Looking back on these events with modern eyes, public reactions to the affair seem to have verged on hysteria.

The Bulgari brooch that lived to tell the tale of “Le Scandale” is truly a timeless classic that looks just as stunning, brilliant, and beautiful as it did when Taylor first acquired it. After her death, many of her jewels were sold at auction and the brooch was acquired by another actress/jewelry collector, Jennifer Tilly, who very kindly lent her piece to the U.S. tour of Italian Style. Unlike some of the other objects in the exhibition, which today might seem a little ’80s shoulder-padded or ’50s matchy-matchy, the brooch seems to come from a place where passing fashions did not exist. But the scandal itself and the extreme reactions it provoked remind us that it isn’t just hemlines and silhouettes that have shifted over the past 50 years—our sensibilities have, too.